Thanks for this, Stephen. I hope you are doing well?
I'm not a financial analyst, I am not even much of a shale oil analyst, just an oilman who understands well economics very well. I can assure everyone at $68/$1 most HZ tight oil wells being drilled today are not cash cows. The sector CAN self finance its current rig count, but no more and it is not deleveraging debt. Its actually adding debt, as one would expect with consolidations. The authors example, Devon, below. IMO a debt to equity ratio of 0.61 is not very healthy when the oil you produce is declining 85+% the first 32 months of production life: Morningstar suggests Devon's breakeven price for oil is $36...sorry, ain't buyin' that. The incremental lift costs per BOE is this article for DVN I do not accept, sorry.
Be very weary of any analysis using BOE as the benchmark and determining what the netback is per BOE. Robert, downhole, is absolutely correct; the two revenue streams (now close to 50/50 in the Delaware Basin) should be analyzed seperately.
I've been thru all this greater "efficiency" stuff a lot recently and I don't see in SEC filings where well costs have come down a lot. They are, as we know, going to skyrocket with tariffs on steel. DVN makes a Lake Erie of produced water every day in the Delaware. Its 2023 wells were not so good and its EUR's are falling. Its 2024 wells may be better on a short term basis, but long term, no.
Consolidations in a mature oil play generally always mean the end is near. I do not agree with RBN's charts at all, but then again, I am not an analyst, just an oil man.
There are two ways to look the U.S. tight oil sector, one from the standpoint of an investment for the sake of dividends, or two, from the standpoint of long term sustainability and the ability to deliver the goods for our nation's long term future. I've learned not to get in chicken fights with dividend owners...they are worse than royalty owners. If that is one's definition of "good for America," dividends, knock yourself out.
On the later, the long term future of tight oil in our country, everything these corporations do are for money and they could care less what the future looks like four years from now for our country.
On this article,