Theoretically, to cut gasoline prices from $3.65 per gallon to $1.82 we're going to have to cut the price of worldwide oil by half, from $72 to $36 per barrel.
If demand for crude oil stays constant, and it likely will, the only way to cut the price of oil, and your gasoline, is to flood the market with more crude oil and drive the price down. Thats the plan with the "Drill Baby, Drill dookey we hear so much of these days.
We're estimating it will take 4.0-4.5 MM MORE barrels per day on the world market to accomplish the $36 per barrel level. There is historical presendence for THAT, actually: in early 2015 the price of WTI was $102, by early 2016 it fell to $31 when 4.5 MM BOPD of U.S. LTO flooded the world market and OPEC would not move over to let America in.
So, where is the new 4 MM BOPD now going to come from?
Well, OPEC is not going to like this plan. If they had 4.0 MM BOPD of spare capacity they don't like $36 oil prices and don't really give a rats ass what Americans pay for gasoline anyway. So I don't think we can count on OPEC to increase their production.
We could lift all sanctions on Russian, Syrian, Iranian and Venzelean oil, that would add way more than 4 MM BOPD to the world market, but the U.S. State Department isn't going to like that plan either. It has its own agenda.
Realistically this 4 plus MM BOPD of additional production is going to come from U.S. shale oil, and particularly the Permian Basin. The Permian has been the only source of worldwide oil production growth for the past 6 years.
In 2017, 2018 and 2019, U.S shale oil grew 1.3 MM BOPD each year. "Those were the days" and the best we could do back then. And it took between 750 HZ rigs running all over the country, from the Canadian border to the Rio Grande to do that, including 520 HZ rigs working in the Permian Basin alone (EIA):
In 2023 we robbed the DUC piggy bank, depleted it down to nothing, and grew tight oil production by 1.0 MM BOPD. So if we put 100 more rigs back to work I am sorta thinking 1 MM BOPD more of US shale oil growth per year is doable. Remember though, we have to drive the price of oil down to $36 and that is going to take 4 years, at 1 MM BOPD increases per year to do that.
What, you didn't actually think your gasoline prices were going down by half on Janaury 21, 2025, did you?
Well, there are some problems even with this plan.
The Permian is running out of steam. First year decline rates are now 73%, up from 47% in 2019, EUR's are going down, big time, the gas monster has the Basin by the ying yang and associated gas and natural gas liquids now represent 50 % of the production stream. Embargos on Chinese steel will drive well costs up, groundwater sources for frac'ing are drying up, produced water injection is causing the earth to sink, heave and belch and...nobody will loan the tight oil sector money anymore to resume the growth over profit thing. Thats a problem.
And by the way, the U.S. shale sector, West Texas or otherwise, doesn't much like $36 oil either. If nobody gives them money, at $36 they are not financially self sufficient. So thats a BIG problem. Where's the money going to come from to add 100 more rigs?
In 2018 when we were rocking and rollin' there were 515 HZ rigs working in the Permian, today there is 304.
And lastly, lets not forget about the freaking legacy decline. Man, that part of the equation sucks !
Every year the U.S. shale sector has to grow 1 MM BOPD of new production its first got to replace 2.5-2.6 MM BOPD of annualize legacy decline. So for the next four years, to drive the price of oil down to $36 a barrel and lower gasoline prices to $1.82 per gallon, like we're being promised, the U.S. tight oil sector has got to yank 3.5 MM BOPD of new production out of the ground each year, for 4 years. Over 4 years thats 14 MM BOPD of new shale oil production by 2029. THEN and only then can your gasoline prices go down by half. Thats reality, sorry.
We currently produce 9 MM BOPD of shale oil in the US, give or take, and it took us 15 years to do that.
So, I don't think this is much of a plan. If it could be done physically, financially, logistically, with Mother Nature's full cooperation, and there were enough able bodied men and women to actually do the work (there is not)...injected produced water from the Permian would bubble up out of the ground in San Antonio. and Austin, hopefully under the TRRC building on N. Congress and that simply would not do.
If we could grow U.S tight oil production by 14 MM BOPD by 2029, we could not sustain that for very long and then we'd Drain Baby, Drain, the very last of America's hydrocarbon resources like somebody pulled the plug on a horse trough.
Then what?
Exxon shouts '' FIRE '' .
https://oilprice.com/Energy/Energy-General/Exxon-Joins-OPEC-in-Warning-of-Looming-Oil-Supply-Crisis.html
I agree with the premise here w.r.t oil. How much of this argument also applies to natural gas?
'' The fossil fuel bonanza is slowly coming to an end. Not with a bang, mind you, but with a whimper: presenting us with a long winding road back to a much simpler life. If you happen to live in a region consuming half of the world’s oil supply, though, the way downhill will be one hell of a ride… And if you think we can innovate ourselves out of this hot mess, then think again and buckle up instead.''
You don't have to be IN the oil and gas business to know how utterly stupid this is, above. This is all about over production of assosciated gas from tight oil wells. By the way, Waha is way closer to what Permian producers are getting paid than HH or HS...after compression, etc. etc, its less than a dollar and if you are on Waha posting, its nothing. That hurts, big time, particularly since rising GOR is putting associated gas close to 50% of the production stream.
Why are they doing this to themselves, the tight oil sector? Because they can't stop drilling. Where is most of this gas going? Up in smoke or vented. Does it hurt the rest of the domestic oil and natural gas industry....what do you think. Will this ultimately hurt the entire country? Damn straight.
This is one of a half dozen examples of why the U.S. shale industry has to be regulated. It is destroying BPH and the mechasim to recover more oil and increase EUR's in tight oil laterals. It cannot self regulate itself and the TRRC, in Texas, is out to lunch. All this for...more crude oil exports to foreign countries.
Drill baby, drill?
Phfttttttt.
Floating storage is close to zero .
https://x.com/aeberman12/status/1827699462178832655/photo/1
Worldwide inventory is getting depleted .
To replace legacy decline and grow Permian tight oil production 4 MM BOPD by 2029, enough oil production growth to lower oil prices to $36 and your gasoline prices to $1.82 per gallon, will take more HZ tight oil wells, drilled in the same core areas, than have already been drilled the past 13 years. Where are they going to put them, where will the money come from to drill them at $36 oil and where in God's name are they going to stuff the produced water?
Bonjour la communauté oilystuff,
bonjour M.Shellman.
Jean Laherrère vient de publier un nouveau papier sur le moyen orient
Ça vaut le détour.
J ai été très surpris voici le lien:
Vous avez de la chance c est en anglais.
Je vais au lit maintenant il est 1h00 du matin en France.
U.S. crude exports rose +0.3 mmb/d from +3.8 to +4.1 mmb/d week ending August 16 Imports increased +0.4 mmb/d to 6.7 mmb/d Net imports rose + 0.1 mmb/d to +2.6 mmb/d .
https://x.com/aeberman12/status/1826982852451340677/photo/1
Repeat post as it is more appropriate here .
Show me the money --- Jerry Maguire .
Show me the spare capacity .
'' Saudi Arabia currently produces exactly the same as four years ago (Aug 2020), or about ~9m b/d Iran and Venezuela together produce ~90% more than four years ago (Aug 2020), or about ~4.3m bpd .
https://x.com/JavierBlas/status/1824359050269561152/photo/1b/d.
This is a great piece of writing, Mike. You have a knack for taking a complex subject and putting it into a concise form that is enjoyable to read. Keep it up!
Not oil related but something to switch on the grey cells . 10 minute read .
'' There is now a widespread belief that AI will inevitably surpass us in terms of intelligence, eventually causing the destruction of humanity… But can such things happen in reality, or is this just another myth we tell ourselves?''
https://thehonestsorcerer.medium.com/an-ai-takeover-not-8e6afe2adb2f